Halloween is the perfect excuse to bake treats that are equal parts spooky and sweet. Cookies are budget-friendly, simple to decorate, and fun for kids and adults alike. With just a few pantry staples and some candy decorations, you can transform plain sugar dough into edible art. Below, you’ll find 25 Halloween cookie ideas that range from silly monsters to eerie spider webs. Each one is easy to make at home, without fancy tools or expensive ingredients.
1. Ghost Sugar Cookies
Ghost cookies are a Halloween classic. All you need is a ghost-shaped cutter and plain sugar dough. Roll it out, cut the shapes, and bake. Use white icing to flood the cookies, then dot on black gel or melted chocolate for the eyes. They look festive without much effort.
For budget savings, skip specialty cutters and cut freehand with a butter knife. Keep the outlines soft—imperfections make them look more ghostly. If baking with kids, let them paint the faces using edible markers. Add variation by sprinkling edible glitter before the icing dries. These cookies store well in tins, making them great for parties or gifting.
2. Jack-O’-Lantern Cookies
Pumpkin-shaped cookies add instant Halloween cheer. Start with a round or oval cutter. Once baked, coat them in orange icing. Add green stems and black faces for personality. Mix up the expressions—some friendly, others scary.
If you don’t want to buy food coloring, tint white icing with a small bit of cocoa powder or turmeric for natural shades. Kids will enjoy drawing the faces with edible pens. Place a few cookies inside treat bags tied with ribbon for simple favors. They’re affordable, fun, and always get smiles at gatherings.
3. Spider Web Cookies
These cookies look impressive but are surprisingly easy. Start with plain round cookies. Flood them with white icing. While it’s still wet, draw circles with black icing. Drag a toothpick outward from the center to create the web.
For budget tips, skip piping bags and use a sandwich bag with a corner cut off. Kids will love helping with the dragging step. Add candy spiders on top for extra fun. They’re a striking addition to a Halloween dessert table.
4. Monster Eyeball Cookies
Monster eyeballs are silly and spooky at the same time. Bake plain cookies, frost them with bold-colored icing, and press on candy eyeballs. For a creepy twist, swirl red food coloring into the icing for bloodshot veins.
If candy eyeballs are pricey, make your own with white chocolate chips and dots of melted chocolate. Kids love adding too many eyes, which makes the cookies extra goofy. They’re perfect for quick last-minute treats.
5. Witch Hat Cookies
These clever cookies require no cutter. Use round chocolate wafers or homemade circles as the base. Pipe a ring of icing and press on a chocolate kiss for the hat point. Add a stripe of orange or purple icing to make a hat band.
This is a budget-friendly recipe since it uses store-bought candy. Kids can easily assemble them without baking. Place them on a tray with candy corn for a colorful display.
6. Black Cat Cookies
Cats are Halloween icons, and black cat cookies set the tone perfectly. Use a cat-shaped cutter or cut simple silhouettes freehand. Frost with black icing and add yellow or green eyes.
For affordable decorating, make the eyes from candy-coated chocolates. If black food coloring is hard to find, mix cocoa with blue coloring to create a dark shade. They’re simple yet dramatic for any Halloween spread.
7. Mummy Cookies
Mummy cookies are easy and crowd-pleasing. Start with rectangles or even graham crackers. Frost with thin white icing lines to mimic bandages. Tuck candy eyes peeking through.
Use a piping bag or zip-top bag to drizzle the “bandages.” For a thrifty option, cut marshmallows into thin strips and stick them on instead. Mummy cookies are fun for kids to decorate at parties.
8. Bat Cookies
Bat cookies are striking and require just one color. Use a bat cutter, then frost with black icing. Add two red dots for glowing eyes.
To keep costs low, make icing with cocoa powder instead of black dye. Kids will enjoy giving their bats different eye colors. Arrange them on a white plate for contrast—they pop beautifully against a pale background.
9. Candy Corn Cookies
These cookies mimic the seasonal candy. Cut triangles from dough and frost in three layers: yellow bottom, orange middle, white top.
If you don’t want to fuss with icing, tint the dough itself with food coloring before baking. It’s a cheaper and faster method. Candy corn cookies are bright, cheerful, and instantly recognizable at any Halloween event.
10. Frankenstein Cookies
Frankenstein cookies bring a fun, silly character to life. Use squares for the face, cover with green icing, and add candy eyes. Draw a jagged black hairline and a stitched smile.
If you don’t have candy eyes, pipe small dots with icing. Pretzel sticks can serve as “bolts” stuck in the sides. These cookies are a budget-friendly way to impress kids and adults alike.
11. Pumpkin Spice Cookies
Not all Halloween cookies need spooky designs. Pumpkin spice cookies deliver cozy fall flavor. Mix pumpkin puree into your dough and roll in cinnamon sugar before baking.
For savings, skip canned pumpkin and roast a fresh one. Serve with hot cider at parties. While simple, they fit beautifully on a Halloween table alongside decorated treats.
12. Skeleton Bone Cookies
Bone cookies add eerie fun. Shape dough into long bones or use a cutter. Frost with white icing. Crack a few for added realism.
For a cheap shortcut, use breadsticks dipped in white chocolate instead. Kids enjoy arranging them into skeletons on serving platters. They’re spooky, affordable, and always get attention.
13. Cauldron Cookies
Cauldron cookies look magical without much work. Bake round cookies and frost them black. Add green icing “potion” inside. Sprinkle with round candies for bubbles.
To save money, use chocolate sandwich cookies as bases. These give a natural cauldron shape. Pair with witch hat cookies for a fun themed platter.
14. Bloody Fang Cookies
Vampire cookies are both eerie and simple. Start with round cookies. Pipe two small fang marks, then let red icing drip like blood.
For a shortcut, press in two mini straws before baking to mark the holes. These cookies are budget-friendly since they don’t require much icing or candy. Great for older kids who like spooky designs.
15. Haunted House Cookies
Turn sugar cookies into mini haunted houses. Cut rectangles or house shapes. Decorate with black icing roofs and glowing yellow windows.
For thrifty decorating, use candy melts or melted chocolate for roofs instead of expensive gel colors. Stand the cookies upright in crushed chocolate cookies to make a haunted cookie village.
16. Coffin Cookies
Coffin cookies are spooky but simple. Use a coffin cutter or trim rectangles into coffin shapes. Frost in black or chocolate icing. Add a white cross or “RIP.”
For savings, make icing crosses with melted white chocolate. Place cookies inside a decorated box for a chilling serving display.
17. Zombie Hand Cookies
Zombie hands are messy fun. Shape dough into simple hand outlines. Frost with green icing and draw cracks or wounds in red. Press candy pieces at the tips for nails.
If cutters feel too pricey, use paper templates and cut by hand. Kids love making these gory designs. Perfect for a gross-out Halloween treat table.
18. Spider Cookies
Spider cookies take minutes to make. Place a chocolate candy in the middle of a baked cookie. Use icing to draw eight legs. Add candy eyes.
A money-saving tip: use peanut butter cups or any leftover candy. These cookies are fast, fun, and a hit with younger kids.
19. Skull Cookies
Skull cookies can be creepy or artistic. Outline skull shapes with black icing, then fill with white. Add colorful decorations for a festive Day of the Dead twist.
To save money, make your own piping bags from parchment. Use sprinkles you already have for decorations. They’re versatile for Halloween or Día de los Muertos parties.
20. Graveyard Dirt Cookies
Graveyard cookies are edible dirt piles. Frost round cookies with chocolate icing. Top with crushed chocolate cookies for dirt. Add candy tombstones and gummy worms.
To keep it affordable, use homemade tombstones cut from graham crackers. These cookies are a playful and budget-friendly centerpiece for Halloween tables.
Conclusion
Halloween cookies don’t need fancy tools or expensive supplies. With a little icing, candy, and creativity, you can turn simple sugar dough into an entire spooky spread. From silly monsters to eerie coffins, these ideas are fun for families, parties, or neighborhood trick-or-treat events. Pick a few, gather your ingredients, and start baking. Your guests will leave impressed—and probably with sticky fingers.
Leave a Reply